Tuesday, 22 July 2014

Team Work

Three Monks, No Water!!

What do you make of it when your OBHR Professor asks you to watch an animated movie in his class? Many people would be surprised to hear such a request but not the students of  IM21 because we have now got used to Dr Mandi's unusual methods and know that there is a lesson hidden in everything he does or asks us to do!!
Never thought learning without any boundaries of classroom can be this enriching and enjoyable.
Commitment and team work can actually work wonders.
                                 SN Brussels Airline Commercial showing Team Work.

The Three Monks

So now moving on to the movie, Three Monks is a Chinese animated feature film directed by A Da. It was released in 1980 and is based on an ancient Chinese proverb "One monk will shoulder two buckets of water, two monks will share the load, but add a third and no one will want to fetch water". 


Important: Watch the video before reading any further!


The Plot :
The Story of the film can be divided into 3 parts based on the number of monks and the work being done by them.

Part I : One monk fetches water to drink

There is only one monk in the monastery and he is responsible for bringing water everyday. The monk fetches the water regularly by carrying two buckets on a stick on his shoulder and there is never shortage of water in the monastery.

Part II : Two monks carry water to drink 


When a second monk arrives, the first monk delegates his task of fetching water to the second monk. The second monk accepts at first but after some time there is a conflict between them over the issue of bring water and they decide that both of them will go together and fetch a single bucket of water.
Note here that now even though two monks are at work, there output has gone down as two monks are fetching only one bucket of water compared to one monk fetching two buckets of water earlier. Also the satisfaction level of the monks has gone own as in the first case, the monk was happy and satisfied while now both the monks seemed dissatisfied.

Part III : Three monks, No water

When a third monk moves in, both monks try to delegate entire work to the newcomer. Like the second monk, the third monk also fetches the water once but he consumes it all by himself. The monks then argue among themselves over whose turn it is to fetch water, nobody fetches water though everybody is thirsty.
Note that now even though we have have three monks and theoretically they should be able to fetch more water than before, things have got stalled completely.

Climax : Crisis Situation - Fire in the Monastery 

Then one fateful night, a fire breaks out in the monastery and the monks keep there ego aside and work together to bring as much water as possible. With their joint effort, they are able to dose out the fire.
 After this incident, they realise how silly they have been and devise a sustainable method of fetching water where their work is divided and hence there is no shortage of water in the monastery forever!

The story of the three monks teaches us that everyone is capable of being selfish, but doing so diminishes our ability to cooperate with one another. Thus we see a totally new phenomenon that as the number of people increase, the productivity has come down drastically.

Without Cooperation, 1 monk can fetch 2 buckets of water, 2 monks can fetch 1 bucket of water and 3 monks will fetch no water at all. 

With cooperation, 3 monks with some innovation on their part can increase the efficiency of the process to a level previously unattainable.

Dr Mandi's point of view :  
But During his lecture. Dr Mandi pointed out that all these lessons are from people's point of view and in an organisation more emphasis should be laid on the processes. People may come and go, but an organisation is forever. Having worked in the services sector for a while, I was a little taken aback by the statement as we were always told that it is the people in an organisation who make that organisation. He explained that instead of supervising people individually, we should develop systems in a way that people have separate tasks and slackers are exposed on their own. This way, the employees will have to take responsibility for the work assigned to them and this will result in high quality relationships and high output.

I would like to end this blog by asking a question to all the prospective future managers, had you been in place of one of the monks, what would have you done to ensure drinking water for yourself and for others?!